Top of 2014 ejuice - thoughts and recommendations please

Tom · 23/10/14

Andre · 23/10/14

Go for it!

Tom · 23/10/14

and it would help to have those threads in a sub forum maybe. Here it may get lost

Tom · 23/10/14

Andre said:
Go for it!

will finalize just now then. afk for an hour or so. maybe a mod can make a sub forum here in the eliquid section in the meantime.

Marzuq · 23/10/14

Tom said:
I would like to do a vote on SA's best juice for 2014.

Here is what I think would work:

I will create 6 more threads, 3 each for international and national juices. Separated in Fruit, dessert and tobacco.

In those threads everyone can name up to 3 juices. This will become a shortlist then. The 10 most named juices would go then into a poll, lets say beginning to mid December, and at the end of the year there would be selected winners.

Thoughts please?

brilliant. i like it. will give us a good idea of whats most popular and what to add to our own wishlists

Imthiaz Khan · 23/10/14

Great idea @Tom

Silver · 23/10/14

Super @Tom
I like what you are doing with these threads.
I will add my inputs on those threads in time.

Perhaps we just need some clarification on what is a Fruit and what is a Dessert

For example, I see you have put Gambit in the Fruit category.
I thought that is an Apple Pie flavour and could be viewed as a Dessert.

Where would I put my Choc Mint?
Dessert?

And some are a mixture of Dessert and Fruit. How shall those be treated?

Not trying to cause problems - just trying to clarify for those who take part.

Tom · 23/10/14

Silver said:
Super @Tom
I like what you are doing with these threads.
I will add my inputs on those threads in time.

Perhaps we just need some clarification on what is a Fruit and what is a Dessert

For example, I see you have put Gambit in the Fruit category.
I thought that is an Apple Pie flavour and could be viewed as a Dessert.

Where would I put my Choc Mint?
Dessert?

And some are a mixture of Dessert and Fruit. How shall those be treated?

Not trying to cause problems - just trying to clarify for those who take part.

thats why i created this posting too....for everyones input

I thought that the "mixed" ones can be named in the group from the members perspective. i.e. Whirling Dervish is a tobacco custard....I feel it is more custard then tobacco and therefore I nominated it in the Dessert group.

However, there should not be the same juice being nominated in 2 categories, I think in that case it should go to the category where it was named mostly. It is first only a shortlist for the final poll.

Silver · 23/10/14

Ok thanks - that clarifies it then

So we put the juice in the category we think fits best - and they will be extracted and sorted out later.

I like it

Paulie · 23/10/14

Very nice idea @Tom !

Tom · 23/10/14

Silver said:
Ok thanks - that clarifies it then

So we put the juice in the category we think fits best - and they will be extracted and sorted out later.

I like it

editing starting posts now

Metal Liz · 23/10/14

Great idea @Tom

Tom · 23/10/14

Tom said:
and it would help to have those threads in a sub forum maybe. Here it may get lost

@Silver or anyone else who can

maybe also something on the start page....for a voting we need as much input as possible!

Tom · 23/10/14

hmm...where would you guys put mentholated juices? Do we need to get another category for that?

Wesley · 23/10/14

I think Menthols deserve their own category.

DoubleD · 23/10/14

Love this idea. Thank you

Silver · 23/10/14

@Tom I like what you are doing here
I like the new category you created for Menthols and Mints
Go for it -

ShaneW · 23/10/14

Brilliant Idea @Tom

Marzuq · 23/10/14

Tom said:
thats why i created this posting too....for everyones input

I thought that the "mixed" ones can be named in the group from the members perspective. i.e. Whirling Dervish is a tobacco custard....I feel it is more custard then tobacco and therefore I nominated it in the Dessert group.

However, there should not be the same juice being nominated in 2 categories, I think in that case it should go to the category where it was named mostly. It is first only a shortlist for the final poll.

@Tom why don't we use yourself seeing as you started the thread and it's your idea, as the point of contact. If we want to nominate a juice we pm the brand and Juice name to you and then you can list of on our behalf. And all we need do is submit a vote. This will avoid multiple entries as well

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

Tom · 23/10/14

Marzuq said:
@Tom why don't we use yourself seeing as you started the thread and it's your idea, as the point of contact. If we want to nominate a juice we pm the brand and Juice name to you and then you can list of on our behalf. And all we need do is submit a vote. This will avoid multiple entries as well

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

thats why i mentioned one post only in the beginning post. it would be too much if i had to be in between...i receive the msg, it might sit for a while in my inbox and then repost the vote.

i will edit the starting post again and stipulate that the first entry will be the one that counts. How is that?

Marzuq · 23/10/14

Tom said:
thats why i mentioned one post only in the beginning post. it would be too much if i had to be in between...i receive the msg, it might sit for a while in my inbox and then repost the vote.

i will edit the starting post again and stipulate that the first entry will be the one that counts. How is that?

That can work. Jst a side note tho. I've noticed that on this forum all of us like to have a say and add in little bits. So keeping track once the thread goes side ways may become a little hard to manage.

Let's see how it goes and if it goes wild we can always freeze the thread. Clean it up and then re-open it again

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

Tom · 23/10/14

Marzuq said:
That can work. Jst a side note tho. I've noticed that on this forum all of us like to have a say and add in little bits. So keeping track once the thread goes side ways may become a little hard to manage.

Let's see how it goes and if it goes wild we can always freeze the thread. Clean it up and then re-open it again

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

yip. so far its been kept clean....i hope it stays that way. otherwise I have to ask admins to remove unnecessary comments

Marzuq · 23/10/14

Tom said:
yip. so far its been kept clean....i hope it stays that way. otherwise I have to ask admins to remove unnecessary comments

Sounds like a plan. Awesome idea tho. I'll be adding my 2c when I'm. In front of my laptop later on

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

Andre · 23/10/14

A coffee category?

Paulie · 23/10/14

nut and candy also

Top of 2014 ejuice - thoughts and recommendations please

Vape Enthusiast

Reonaut

Vape Enthusiast

Vape Enthusiast

Goofy Guru

Flavor chaser

Flavour and throat hit seeker

Vape Enthusiast

Flavour and throat hit seeker

Flavour master

Vape Enthusiast

Vaping Addict

Vape Enthusiast

Vape Enthusiast

Dedicated Vaper

Vaporous Maximus

Flavour and throat hit seeker

Juicy Joes Owner

Goofy Guru

Vape Enthusiast

Goofy Guru

Vape Enthusiast

Goofy Guru

Reonaut

Flavour master

Similar threads